Dave Meltzer's Match Ratings: The Ultimate Guide

Dave Meltzer match ratings are widely regarded as the most respected and influential professional wrestling match rating system in the world. Meltzer, a renowned journalist and historian in the professional wrestling industry, has been providing his match ratings for over three decades. His ratings are based on a scale of 0 to 5 stars, with 5 stars being the highest rating possible. Meltzer's ratings are highly sought after by fans and critics alike, as they are seen as an accurate and fair assessment of the quality of a match.

Meltzer's match ratings have played an important role in the development of professional wrestling. His ratings have helped to raise the profile of the industry and have made it more accessible to mainstream audiences. Meltzer's ratings have also helped to establish a standard for what is considered to be a "great" match. His ratings have been used by promoters to determine the main event of major wrestling shows and have even been used by wrestlers to negotiate their contracts.

The main article will delve deeper into the history, methodology, and impact of Dave Meltzer match ratings. It will also provide a list of some of the highest-rated matches in Meltzer's history.

Dave Meltzer Match Ratings

Dave Meltzer match ratings are widely regarded as the most respected and influential professional wrestling match rating system in the world. Meltzer, a renowned journalist and historian in the professional wrestling industry, has been providing his match ratings for over three decades. His ratings are based on a scale of 0 to 5 stars, with 5 stars being the highest rating possible. Meltzer's ratings are highly sought after by fans and critics alike, as they are seen as an accurate and fair assessment of the quality of a match.

• Credibility: Meltzer has a reputation for being fair and unbiased in his ratings.
• Experience: Meltzer has been covering professional wrestling for over three decades and has seen thousands of matches.
• Influence: Meltzer's ratings are used by promoters to determine the main event of major wrestling shows and have even been used by wrestlers to negotiate their contracts.
• Legacy: Meltzer's match ratings have played an important role in the development of professional wrestling.
• Objectivity: Meltzer's ratings are based on a set of objective criteria, such as the psychology of the match, the execution of the moves, and the crowd reaction.
• Controversy: Meltzer's ratings are not without their critics, but they are generally considered to be the most accurate and fair assessment of the quality of a match.
• Entertainment: Meltzer's ratings are not just about the technical aspects of a match, they also take into account the entertainment value.
• Star ratings: Meltzer's 5-star rating system is the most well-known and respected in professional wrestling.

In conclusion, Dave Meltzer match ratings are important because they provide a fair and accurate assessment of the quality of a match. Meltzer's ratings are based on a set of objective criteria and take into account the psychology of the match, the execution of the moves, the crowd reaction, and the entertainment value. Meltzer's ratings have played an important role in the development of professional wrestling and are used by promoters and wrestlers alike.

1. Credibility

The credibility of Dave Meltzer's match ratings is a key factor in their importance. Meltzer has a reputation for being fair and unbiased in his ratings, which means that fans and critics alike trust his judgment. This credibility is built on a number of factors, including Meltzer's experience, knowledge, and objectivity.

Meltzer has been covering professional wrestling for over three decades and has seen thousands of matches. This experience gives him a deep understanding of the sport and the factors that make a great match. Meltzer is also a student of the history of professional wrestling, which gives him a unique perspective on the evolution of the sport.

In addition to his experience and knowledge, Meltzer is also known for his objectivity. He is not afraid to give a low rating to a match that he did not enjoy, even if it is a match that is popular with fans. This objectivity is essential for maintaining the credibility of his ratings.

The credibility of Meltzer's match ratings is important for a number of reasons. First, it means that fans can trust his ratings to be an accurate assessment of the quality of a match. Second, it means that promoters can use Meltzer's ratings to help them determine which matches to book for their shows. Third, it means that wrestlers can use Meltzer's ratings to help them improve their performance. Ultimately, the credibility of Meltzer's match ratings is what makes them so valuable to fans, critics, and wrestlers alike.

2. Experience

Meltzer's experience is a key factor in the credibility of his match ratings. He has seen thousands of matches over the course of his career, which gives him a deep understanding of the sport and the factors that make a great match. This experience allows him to make informed judgments about the quality of a match, and his ratings are widely respected by fans and critics alike.

• Breadth of knowledge: Meltzer's experience has given him a broad knowledge of professional wrestling. He is familiar with the different styles of wrestling, the different promotions, and the different wrestlers. This knowledge allows him to make accurate comparisons between matches and to assess their quality in the context of the wrestling landscape.
• Historical perspective: Meltzer's experience also gives him a historical perspective on professional wrestling. He has seen the evolution of the sport over the years and is able to compare matches from different eras. This perspective allows him to make informed judgments about the quality of a match in the context of wrestling history.
• Objectivity: Meltzer's experience helps him to be objective in his ratings. He is not swayed by personal bias or by the popularity of a wrestler or promotion. He simply calls it as he sees it, which is why his ratings are so respected.

Ultimately, Meltzer's experience is what makes his match ratings so valuable. He has the knowledge, the perspective, and the objectivity to make accurate and fair assessments of the quality of a match.

3. Influence

Dave Meltzer's match ratings are not just a measure of the quality of a match, they are also a powerful tool that can be used to influence the wrestling business. Promoters use Meltzer's ratings to determine the main event of major wrestling shows, and wrestlers use Meltzer's ratings to negotiate their contracts.

• Main event determination: Meltzer's ratings are often used by promoters to determine the main event of major wrestling shows. A match with a high Meltzer rating is more likely to be booked as the main event than a match with a low Meltzer rating. This is because Meltzer's ratings are seen as an accurate reflection of the quality of a match, and promoters want to put on the best possible main event for their fans.
• Contract negotiation: Wrestlers can also use Meltzer's ratings to negotiate their contracts. A wrestler with a high Meltzer rating is more likely to be able to negotiate a higher salary and better working conditions. This is because Meltzer's ratings are seen as an indication of a wrestler's ability and popularity, and promoters are willing to pay more for wrestlers who are highly rated by Meltzer.

The influence of Meltzer's match ratings on the wrestling business is undeniable. Meltzer's ratings are used by promoters to determine the main event of major wrestling shows and by wrestlers to negotiate their contracts. This influence is a testament to the credibility and respect that Meltzer has earned within the wrestling industry.

4. Legacy

Dave Meltzer's match ratings have had a profound impact on the development of professional wrestling. His ratings have helped to raise the profile of the industry and have made it more accessible to mainstream audiences. Meltzer's ratings have also helped to establish a standard for what is considered to be a "great" match.

One of the most important ways that Meltzer's ratings have influenced the development of professional wrestling is by helping to legitimize the industry. In the past, professional wrestling was often seen as a form of low-brow entertainment. However, Meltzer's ratings have helped to show that professional wrestling can be a legitimate sport. Meltzer's ratings have also helped to attract new fans to professional wrestling. By providing a way to measure the quality of matches, Meltzer's ratings have made it easier for fans to find matches that they will enjoy.

In addition to legitimizing the industry and attracting new fans, Meltzer's ratings have also helped to improve the quality of professional wrestling. By providing a way to measure the quality of matches, Meltzer's ratings have given wrestlers an incentive to improve their performance. Wrestlers know that if they can get a high rating from Meltzer, it will help them to get more exposure and earn more money. This has led to a in the overall quality of professional wrestling.

Dave Meltzer's match ratings have played an important role in the development of professional wrestling. His ratings have helped to legitimize the industry, attract new fans, and improve the quality of professional wrestling. Meltzer's ratings are a valuable tool for fans, critics, and wrestlers alike, and they will continue to play an important role in the development of professional wrestling for years to come.

5. Objectivity

Objectivity is a key factor in the credibility of Dave Meltzer's match ratings. Meltzer's ratings are based on a set of objective criteria, such as the psychology of the match, the execution of the moves, and the crowd reaction. This objectivity ensures that Meltzer's ratings are not influenced by personal bias or favoritism.

• Psychology of the match: Meltzer's ratings take into account the psychology of the match, such as the story that is being told, the character development, and the emotional connection between the wrestlers. A match with a strong psychology will typically receive a higher rating than a match that is simply a series of moves.
• Execution of the moves: Meltzer's ratings also take into account the execution of the moves, such as the technical skill of the wrestlers and the smoothness of the transitions. A match with well-executed moves will typically receive a higher rating than a match with sloppy execution.
• Crowd reaction: Meltzer's ratings also take into account the crowd reaction, such as the level of excitement and engagement of the audience. A match with a hot crowd will typically receive a higher rating than a match with a dead crowd.

By taking into account these objective criteria, Meltzer's ratings provide a fair and accurate assessment of the quality of a match. Meltzer's objectivity is essential for maintaining the credibility of his ratings and ensuring that they are respected by fans, critics, and wrestlers alike.

6. Controversy

Dave Meltzer's match ratings are not without their critics. Some critics argue that Meltzer's ratings are too subjective and that he is biased towards certain wrestlers and promotions. Others argue that Meltzer's ratings are too focused on technical wrestling and that he does not give enough credit to other aspects of a match, such as storytelling and psychology.

Despite these criticisms, Meltzer's ratings are generally considered to be the most accurate and fair assessment of the quality of a match. Meltzer has a deep understanding of professional wrestling and his ratings are based on a set of objective criteria, such as the psychology of the match, the execution of the moves, and the crowd reaction. Meltzer is also known for his objectivity and he is not afraid to give a low rating to a match that he did not enjoy, even if it is a match that is popular with fans.

The controversy surrounding Meltzer's ratings is actually one of the things that makes them so valuable. Meltzer's ratings are not simply a reflection of his own personal opinion. They are a reflection of the wider wrestling community, and they provide a unique insight into the different ways that people view professional wrestling. Meltzer's ratings can be used to spark debate and discussion, and they can help fans to better understand the art of professional wrestling.

Ultimately, the importance of Meltzer's ratings lies in their ability to provide an accurate and fair assessment of the quality of a match. Meltzer's ratings are not perfect, but they are the best that we have. They are a valuable tool for fans, critics, and wrestlers alike, and they will continue to play an important role in the world of professional wrestling for years to come.

7. Entertainment

In addition to the technical aspects of a match, Meltzer's ratings also take into account the entertainment value. This is an important factor because professional wrestling is, at its core, a form of entertainment. Fans want to be entertained when they watch a wrestling match, and Meltzer's ratings reflect this.

There are a number of factors that contribute to the entertainment value of a match, such as the charisma of the wrestlers, the story that is being told, and the crowd reaction. Meltzer takes all of these factors into account when he is rating a match. A match with a great story and a hot crowd will typically receive a higher rating than a match with poor storytelling and a dead crowd, even if the technical execution of the match is the same.

The entertainment value of a match is subjective, but Meltzer's ratings provide a valuable insight into what fans are looking for in a wrestling match. Meltzer's ratings can help fans to find matches that they will enjoy, and they can also help wrestlers to improve their performance by giving them feedback on what fans want to see.

Ultimately, the entertainment value of a match is up to the individual fan to decide. However, Meltzer's ratings provide a valuable starting point for fans who are looking for a great match to watch.

8. Star ratings

Dave Meltzer's 5-star rating system is a key component of his match ratings. The star rating is a quick and easy way to communicate the quality of a match to fans, and Meltzer's 5-star system is the most well-known and respected in professional wrestling.

Meltzer's 5-star rating system is based on a 1-to-5 scale, with 5 stars being the highest rating possible. Meltzer awards 5 stars to matches that he considers to be exceptional, and these matches are often considered to be among the best matches in professional wrestling history.

The star rating system is important because it provides a way to compare the quality of different matches. Fans can use the star ratings to find matches that they are likely to enjoy, and promoters can use the star ratings to determine which matches to book for their shows.

Here are some examples of matches that have received 5-star ratings from Meltzer:

• Kenny Omega vs. Kazuchika Okada (Wrestle Kingdom 11)
• AJ Styles vs. John Cena (SummerSlam 2016)
• The Young Bucks vs. The Lucha Brothers (All In 2018)
• WALTER vs. Tyler Bate (NXT UK TakeOver: Cardiff)
• Shingo Takagi vs. Will Ospreay (New Japan Pro-Wrestling Wrestle Kingdom 14)

These are just a few examples of the many matches that have received 5-star ratings from Meltzer. His star rating system is a valuable tool for fans and promoters alike, and it has helped to raise the profile of professional wrestling.

FAQs on Dave Meltzer Match Ratings

This section provides answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about Dave Meltzer match ratings, offering further clarification and insights into their significance and usage.

Question 1: What are the criteria used by Dave Meltzer in his match ratings?

Answer: Dave Meltzer's match ratings encompass a comprehensive evaluation of various elements that contribute to the overall quality of a wrestling match. These criteria include the psychology of the match, the execution of moves, the crowd reaction, the storytelling, the innovativeness of the match, and the overall impact it leaves on the audience. By considering these factors, Meltzer aims to provide a holistic assessment of a match's quality.

Question 2: How does Meltzer's star rating system work?

Answer: Meltzer utilizes a 5-star rating system, with 5 stars representing the highest possible rating. Matches that receive this rating are considered exceptional and are often regarded as some of the finest in professional wrestling history. Meltzer awards star ratings based on his assessment of the match's overall quality, taking into account the various criteria mentioned above.

Question 3: Are Meltzer's ratings subjective or objective?

Answer: While Meltzer's match ratings are based on his personal judgment and observations, they are not purely subjective. Meltzer establishes a set of objective criteria that guide his evaluations, ensuring consistency and fairness in his ratings. He considers technical proficiency, storytelling, crowd engagement, and other quantifiable factors to provide a well-rounded assessment.

Question 4: How influential are Meltzer's ratings in the wrestling industry?

Answer: Meltzer's match ratings hold significant influence within the professional wrestling industry. Promoters often use his ratings to determine the placement of matches on event cards, with higher-rated matches receiving more prominent positions. Additionally, wrestlers themselves value Meltzer's ratings, as they can impact their reputation, marketability, and career trajectory.

Question 5: Have Meltzer's ratings ever been controversial?

Answer: Yes, Meltzer's ratings have occasionally sparked controversy within the wrestling community. Some critics argue that his ratings are biased towards certain wrestlers or promotions. Others contend that he places too much emphasis on technical execution and undervalues other aspects of a match, such as storytelling or entertainment value. Despite these criticisms, Meltzer's ratings remain widely respected for their consistency, objectivity, and influence.

Question 6: How can fans use Meltzer's match ratings?

Answer: Dave Meltzer's match ratings serve as a valuable resource for wrestling fans. They can use these ratings to discover high-quality matches, compare the performances of different wrestlers, and gain insights into the strengths and weaknesses of various promotions. Meltzer's ratings can also stimulate discussion and debate among fans, fostering a deeper appreciation and understanding of professional wrestling.

In summary, Dave Meltzer match ratings offer a comprehensive and influential evaluation of professional wrestling matches. Based on a set of objective criteria, Meltzer's star rating system provides valuable insights into match quality, impacting the industry and informing fans' perspectives on the sport.

Transition to the next article section:

For further exploration into the world of professional wrestling, continue reading the next section, where we delve into the captivating history and evolution of this dynamic sport.

Tips for Understanding Dave Meltzer Match Ratings

Following are a few tips to assist in comprehending and utilizing Dave Meltzer match ratings:

Tip 1: Consider the Criteria

Familiarize yourself with the criteria Meltzer employs in his ratings. These encompass technical execution, psychology, storytelling, crowd reaction, and overall impact. Understanding these elements enhances your ability to interpret and appreciate his ratings.

Tip 2: Contextualize the Ratings

Recognize that Meltzer's ratings are subjective and influenced by his personal perspective. While generally regarded as fair and well-informed, they may not always align with individual opinions. Consider multiple sources and perspectives to form a well-rounded understanding.

Tip 3: Utilize the Star System

Meltzer's 5-star rating system offers a quick and convenient method to gauge match quality. 5 stars represent exceptional matches, while lower ratings indicate varying degrees of quality. Use these ratings as a general guideline, keeping in mind that personal preferences may differ.

Tip 4: Explore High-Rated Matches

Seek out matches that have received high ratings from Meltzer. These matches often showcase exceptional storytelling, technical prowess, and crowd engagement. By experiencing these matches firsthand, you can develop a deeper understanding of Meltzer's criteria and enhance your appreciation for quality wrestling.

Tip 5: Engage in Discussions

Participate in discussions and forums related to Meltzer's match ratings. Engage with other fans, share your perspectives, and learn from diverse viewpoints. These discussions can provide valuable insights and expand your understanding of match evaluation.

Summary

By following these tips, you can effectively utilize Dave Meltzer match ratings to enhance your enjoyment and understanding of professional wrestling. Remember that ratings are subjective, but they offer a valuable framework for assessing match quality and fueling discussions among wrestling enthusiasts.

Transition to the article's conclusion:

In conclusion, Dave Meltzer match ratings have significantly contributed to the landscape of professional wrestling. They provide a widely recognized and respected system for evaluating match quality, guiding fans, informing industry decisions, and fostering discussions. By embracing these tips, you can harness the insights offered by Meltzer's ratings to enrich your wrestling experience.

Conclusion

Dave Meltzer match ratings have profoundly impacted the professional wrestling industry, establishing a respected system for evaluating match quality. Meltzer's comprehensive criteria, encompassing technical execution, psychology, storytelling, crowd reaction, and overall impact, provide a valuable framework for assessing matches. His 5-star rating system offers a convenient and widely recognized method for gauging match quality.

Meltzer's ratings have influenced booking decisions, wrestler reputations, and fan discussions. They have helped legitimize professional wrestling as a sport, showcasing its athleticism and storytelling capabilities. Meltzer's objectivity and consistency have earned him widespread respect, making his ratings a trusted source for fans and industry professionals alike.

As professional wrestling continues to evolve, Dave Meltzer match ratings will undoubtedly remain a significant part of the landscape. They offer a valuable tool for fans to discover exceptional matches, compare wrestlers' performances, and gain insights into the intricacies of the sport. By embracing Meltzer's ratings and understanding their nuances, fans can deepen their appreciation for professional wrestling and engage in informed discussions about its quality.